Papersby GlyphChasing the Tail: Effective Rubric-based Reward Modeling for Large Language Model Post-Training research paper by Scale AI, 2025
Scale AI · Training and scaling · Sep 25, 2025 · 62 citations · 20 upvotes
What it shows
Rubric-based rewards mitigate reward over-optimization in reinforcement fine-tuning by leveraging off-policy examples while maintaining reward reliability.
By Junkai Zhang, Zihao Wang, Lin Gui and 7 more · arXiv 2509.21500 · PDF · Code
Hugging Face's summary; not yet checked by hand.
More from Scale AI
All 25Root-Cause Attribution Is a Search Problem: Continual Search for Long-Horizon Agent FailuresContinual Search improves automated root-cause attribution in long agent execution traces by iteratively prompting diagnosis until unresolved evidence is found.
Scale AI5 upvotesRead →SteerDuplex: Steerable Duplex Speech Dialogue ModelsA full-duplex speech model that follows spoken instructions on tone, persona, pace and voice, with a benchmark of 390 prompts to test it.Scale AI3 citations6 upvotesRead →Studying Without a Syllabus: Task-Agnostic Environment PreprocessingAn agent can explore unfamiliar environments without task-specific guidance to build reusable artifacts that reduce later inference costs, though larger study budgets do not always improve results.Scale AI1 citations4 upvotesRead →HarnessOpt-Bench: Evaluating LLMs at Harness OptimizationHarnessOpt-Bench measures how well frontier LLMs iteratively improve agent harnesses under constrained evaluation budgets, revealing substantial variation across models and tasks.Scale AI12 citations35 upvotesRead →Model or Harness? An Interaction-Centric Taxonomy for Localizing Agent FailuresAn interaction-centric taxonomy localizes agent failures to specific component interactions to guide targeted repairs across diverse architectures.Scale AI11 citations10 upvotesRead →SWE-INTERACT: Reimagining SWE Benchmarks as User-Driven Long-Horizon Coding SessionsSWE-Interact presents a testbed that evaluates coding agents in realistic multi-turn, user-driven software engineering scenarios, revealing significant gaps between single-turn performance and interactive task completion.Scale AI23 citations7 upvotesRead →Not Every Rubric Teaches Equally: Policy-Aware Rubric Rewards for RLVRPOW3R is a policy-aware framework for reinforcement learning with rubric-based rewards that adapts criterion weights during training to improve policy optimization while preserving human-defined criteria importance.Scale AI13 citations5 upvotesRead →Reward Hacking in Rubric-Based Reinforcement LearningResearch examines reward hacking in rubric-based reinforcement learning, identifying verifier failure and rubric-design limitations as key sources of divergence between training and evaluation metrics.Scale AI33 citations4 upvotesRead →
Other training and scaling papers
TopicLoRA: Low-Rank Adaptation of Large Language ModelsLoRA fine-tunes a large model by training small low-rank matrices, cutting trainable parameters by 10,000 times.
Microsoft25.6k citations66 upvotesRead →Scaling Laws for Neural Language ModelsLanguage model loss falls as a smooth power law as model size, data and compute grow.
OpenAI9,592 citations12 upvotesRead →Training Compute-Optimal Large Language ModelsChinchilla: for a fixed compute budget, train a smaller model on more data; parameters and tokens should grow together.
Google DeepMind4,035 citations13 upvotesRead →Megatron-LM: Training Multi-Billion Parameter Language Models Using Model ParallelismMegatron-LM splits each Transformer layer across GPUs to train models with billions of parameters.
NVIDIA3,387 citations5 upvotesRead →DeepSeek LLM: Scaling Open-Source Language Models with LongtermismDeepSeek LLM, an open-source language model project, develops a large dataset and employs SFT and DPO to achieve performance surpassing LLaMA-2 70B and GPT-3.5 in various benchmarks and open-ended evaluations.
DeepSeek872 citations56 upvotesRead →LoRA Learns Less and Forgets LessLoRA learns less than full fine-tuning on code and math, but forgets less of what the model already knew.
Databricks486 citations91 upvotesRead →
About this paper
- Venue
- International Conference on Learning Representations
- Citations
- 62, 3 influential · Semantic Scholar
- Upvotes
- 20 · Hugging Face
- Lab
- Scale AI · on Companies · on Acquisitions · on awards · on breaches · on Attested · on Rounds · on Downtime · on labs · on Leaders · on marketplaces · on Allied · on Paydays · on quotes · on salaries · on Nines · on socials · on startups · on terms · on Titlewave
Changes
Citations rose from 61 to 62.
Citations rose from 50 to 61.
Citations rose from 46 to 50.
A first count of 3 influential citations.
A first count of 46 citations.
Added to the list.